Best Secret Santa Gift Box Ideas for Coworkers & Extended Family (2024)

Updated by Guest Contributor

Finding the perfect Secret Santa gift can be a daunting task, especially if it's for a coworker that you don’t know too much about (other than the emojis they like to use when responding to a Slack message) or a distant aunt you’ve only met once during a birthday party. Cratejoy marketplace has a gift box that's just for them! You'll find gift baskets geared towards music nerds , crafters, self-care enthusiasts, and card game enthusiasts .

Is the gift exchange date looming near? Have no fear, we’ve got the best Secret Santa gift box ideas (that’ll ship before Christmas!) for your buddies that’ll show everyone in the gift exchange how much thought you put into picking out a gift. Buy a single box or a gift that keeps on giving to bring holiday cheer throughout the rest of the year.

The Adults & Crafts Crate

The Adults & Crafts Crate

From $32.00 per box
Buy Now

There’s no need to get bogged down in project planning when the pros behind the Adults & Crafts Crate have got it covered. Each monthly box sends at least 1 new Pinterest-worthy craft project, including all the supplies, tools, and illustrated step-by-steps to teach new crafting techniques while making one-of-a-kind keepsakes.

Shipping: New orders will ship within five business days! If you need a gift printout before we ship, just message us! Then, will ship around the 25th of each month. If you need a kit by a certain date (i.e. birthday), just message us after you order and we will get that set up for you! You can order now even if you want it to start in the future.

Customer Review

"I received the engraving kit and I love it! I practiced on an old glass weigh scale to get the hang of engraving. I then started the glass coasters using pictures off google. I am sooo happy with how they turned out! It’s very relaxing and is a great stress reliever. I have a few people now wanting me to make them sets of coasters :)" - Megan T.

Finders Seekers Mysteries

Finders Seekers Mysteries

From $26.40 per box
Buy Now

Solve puzzles while traveling the world with this thrilling escape room game! Finders Seekers is the perfect gift for puzzle solvers and mystery fans who loves a challenge! Enjoy this game with the family or venture off and uncover complex clues with a single use mystery game inclusive of hands-on and online gameplay.

Shipping: We ship on the 23rd of each month, for all orders placed by the 21st. All subsequent games will ship by the 23rd of each month. For last-minute gifts, we provide a fun PDF gift message that you can personalize and email or print. Shipping is $6 within the US, Canada shipping: $7.95.

Customer Review

“I have been getting Finders Seekers boxes for over a year, and I cannot lie, I'm obsessed. The mysteries are a lot of fun, and they are so much fun to do with friends, especially those that haven't done something like this before. Occasionally, the puzzles are evil (I'm looking at you, Paris box!), but the fact that after a year they can still challenge me is a good thing.” - Rachel C.

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Club

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Club

From $49.91 per box
Buy Now

Mix things up by giving them a craft cocktail subscription box. Each month, subscribers will get three unique and tasty cocktail recipes, along with everything needed (minus the liquor) to whip up 12 delicious drinks. Every Shaker & Spoon box focuses on a specific liquor, so they’ll be able to make the most of their home bar. Whether they’re celebrating a special occasion, getting together with friends, or just building their bartender expertise, this monthly box will have subscribers raising a glass in delight.

Shipping: The Kick Back with Cognac Box is shipping now! **IF YOU EVER NEED A BOX SOONER, WRITE TO US by clicking the CONTACT SELLER button (bottom of the page) and we’ll hook you up with a different box from our vault!**

Customer Review

"Gave this as a gift and got to try some of the cocktails. The cachaca box was really fun! Really interesting combinations and usually some ingredients leftover for another batch of cocktails." - Leyna M.

Jerky Snob

Jerky Snob

From $15.49 per box
Buy Now

Jerky Snob takes dried meats seriously. Beef jerky makes for the perfect snack for road trips, while watching Netflix, and even on the way to the gym. Whether they're a dried meat connoisseur or looking for another source of protein, Jerky Snob curates premium handcrafted jerky from small-batch artisans. Choose between 3 different levels, sending from 2 bags up to a full pound, for a variety of protein-packed tasty products.

Shipping: **Shipping not included. Ships to the U.S. ONLY (all 50 states, 5 territories, and APOs.) New orders ship in 1-3 business days, or the date specified. (Gifts ship in logo package via USPS). Regular shipment is 12-16th of each month. No pork allowed? Dietary restrictions? Questions? Scroll to the bottom and click "Contact Seller."

Customer Review

“My S.O. loved these! I got this for him for his birthday and he thoroughly enjoyed looking forward to a new delivery each month. The jerky was really good, exceptionally fresh! Even his least favorite jerky's, the sugar free ones, were pretty good. They just need some kin of sweetness to balance out the flavor. All in all this was a wonderful experience and will be my first stop for future gifts!” -Donna H.

SnackSack Classic

SnackSack Classic

From $26.91 per box
Buy Now

Looking for the ultimate snacking subscription? This box delivers between 11 and 13 surprise snacks every month centered around a fun or seasonal theme. There are four snacking plans to fit different lifestyles: classic, vegan, gluten-free, or vegan and gluten-free.

Shipping: Secure your April SnackSack today, shipping on April 18th! Act fast – limited quantities available until sold out. Don't miss out on our "Mother Earth" theme, celebrating Earth Day with an array of refreshing snacks and spring flavors! Order now to guarantee your spot in this delicious adventure!

Customer Review

“I am enjoying everything that came in my monthly box, there wasn't a bad snack in the entire selection! Also, I love the cute bag to keep my snacks in; it's a really nice touch. I can't wait to see what other delights are in the other months to come.” — Kareema B.

British Dessert Baking Kits

British Dessert Baking Kits

From $36.99 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: **PLEASE NOTE** ALL subscriptions (no matter when placed) will start Jan 2024, orders will be taken until the end of December 2023 (whilst stock is available). A certificate will be issued via email to present to your recipient in place of the gift whilst they wait for the first box to ship. Boxes will ship the beginning of Jan, Feb and March.

Monthly Raw Honey

Monthly Raw Honey

From $27.49 per box
Buy Now

It’s the sweetest complement to your tea lover’s daily cup. Honeycomber Club delivers premium raw honey from family-owned and operated bee farms. And, each box includes informational leaflets describing each honey in the monthly curation.

Shipping: For orders placed within the first two weeks of the month, we make every effort to ship those orders that month. However, sometimes due to staffing and supply chain, orders may be shipped in next month's batch. We apologize for any inconvenience.

Customer Review

“Love the variety and information on these honeys! Jars are nice sizes, not just samples, and subscription is a very reasonable cost. One of my favorite subscriptions!” -Linda C.

Bath Bevy Subscription - Monthly

Bath Bevy Subscription - Monthly

From $39.56 per box
Buy Now

Help them reduce stress and relax with a calming, luxurious bath experience from Bath Bevy. This thoughtfully curated subscription offers handmade bath and body products like bath bombs, soaps, scrubs, bath salts, bubble bath and more. Don’t have a tub? Bath Bevy now has a “tubless” option with shower steamers, lotions, body wash, whipped soaps and more.

Shipping: Subscribe now for the November Warm and Cozy box - shipping the first week of November via USPS Priority Mail. Following boxes ship the first week of the month.

Customer Review

"I have been subscribed to this box for 5 months and I love it every month! Everything smells amazing and none of the products bother my skin. I have eczema and can’t use most store bought scented products. I love the themes every month and everything is super cute!" - Lauren E.


Coworkers, friends, sorority sisters and bigger-than-big extended families have drawn names for their annual Secret Santa exchange. While this holiday gift tradition is meant to bring the joy of gift giving to the holiday season, there's a lot of pressure to get it right, or, at least get a laugh !

Didn't find the right gift for your Secret Santa gift exchange?